Knowledgable.
Efficient.
Aggressive.
Successful.

What if a verbal agreement exists with the previous owner?

On Behalf of | Sep 5, 2025 | Real Estate |

In the past, people often made verbal agreements without thinking about the need for legal documents. Now, imagine you are a new owner demanding that people leave your property because they lack proof of a lease. This situation can be tricky, especially when squatters claim they had a verbal agreement with the previous owner. Let us explore how to handle this situation with care and understanding.

What is the strength of a verbal agreement in Pennsylvania?

In Pennsylvania, verbal agreements can be legally binding. Nonetheless, proving their existence or their validity can be challenging. Verbal agreements rely on trust and memory, which can fade over time. The Statute of Frauds requires most contracts to be in writing. When dealing with real estate, it is always best to have a written agreement to avoid future misunderstandings. Without solid proof, such as witnesses or documents, it is difficult to prove the terms of the agreement.

How to gather evidence and document the situation?

When handling someone who claims to have a verbal agreement, it is important to take note of details. Here are steps to build your case:

  • Collect any written communication between the previous owner and the occupant
  • Photograph the property’s condition and any alterations made by the occupant
  • Obtain statements from neighbors or witnesses familiar with the situation
  • Review property records and tax documents

These pieces of evidence can help establish the nature of the occupancy and support your legal position.

How to communicate with the occupant?

When you speak to them, make sure to listen carefully to their side of the story. Understanding their perspective can help in finding a solution that works for both parties. It is important to show respect and patience during this conversation, as it sets a positive tone for resolving the issue. Sometimes, showing a willingness to find a middle ground can prevent further conflicts and help maintain a good relationship.
If the conversation does not lead to a resolution, consider seeking advice from a legal expert. They can provide guidance on how to proceed while respecting everyone’s rights. Remember, the goal is to find a solution that is fair and satisfactory for both sides, minimizing any potential disputes.

What may happen if squatters stay without proof of lease?

If you consider allowing squatters to remain on your property it may lead to potential problems. These include legal liability, property damage and decreased property value. Without proof of a valid lease, the state will consider them unauthorized occupants. Addressing the situation promptly and legally is essential to protect your investment and avoid future complications.
It would be wise to consult with a real estate attorney. Legally, they can help you understand your rights and the options available to you. They can also help you evaluate the strength of the squatter’s claim and advise you on the best course of action.

 

Archives